by: Okky Madasari

A half century after the first defeat of the imagination of a short story in court, leading to the imprisonment of leading literature critic HB Jassin, we have lost a second battle against irrationality, arrogance and backwardness.

Again we are witnessing the curbing of creativity that should otherwise flourish and bring this nation forward into the realm of reason and progress.

Back in 1968, Jassin, then-chief editor of Sastra (Literature) magazine, was jailed for blasphemy as he had published a story which had personalized God and Prophet Muhammad, a taboo in Islam. Titled Langit Makin Mendung (The Darkening Sky), it was written by Kipandjikusmin, a pen name whose real identity Jassin refused to disclose.

The courage of North Sumatra University (USU) students to bring their case to court this year sparked hope that reason would prevail this time. But the Medan State Administrative Court decided to be on the wrong side of history, ruling against the creativity of our young people.

In mid-November the court rejected a lawsuit against the rector filed by students working with the Suara USU student website who had been fired from the editorial board for publishing a short story accused of containing pornography and lesbian, bisexual, gay and transgender (LBGT) issues.

The court’s ruling was not only deeply disappointing for me personally as an expert witness for the students in the case, but it profoundly hurt the already dwindling condition of freedom and freedom of expression, as well as hard-fought efforts to create a just legal system in this country.

The ruling will become a bad precedent for any case against media shutdowns and will be a dent on freedom of expression for a long time to come.

Fifty years ago, against the backdrop of the Cold War and the ghost of communism, maybe there was understandably low public support for writers and literature, compared to loud defenders of religious teachings.

But even then, the records show rigorous debates between those who accused the story of blasphemy and those who strongly believed the story was about social criticism.

Like the trial from decades ago, the Suara USU trial is not so much about legal reasoning. It’s about interpretation of the short story in question; whether the story is pornography or not, promoting LGBT or not.

As I told the court, the short story Ketika Semua Menolak Kehadiran Diriku di Dekatnya (When Everyone Refuses My Presence Near Her) is not pornography at all. A story, book or film can be categorized as pornography if it is created merely to make the audiences aroused and if the content, be it the story line or the aesthetic aspects, only serves to stimulate sexual desire and imagination.

However, the story by Yael Stefany Sinaga does not contain any suggestion of sexual stimulation or any intention of arousing sexual desire at all. It’s a story about girl falling in love with another girl and publicly expressing it, but the latter girl rejects her. When everybody finds out, including both families, the main character is heavily condemned. She feels rejected by her surroundings.

It’s as simple as that. No kissing, no hugging and certainly no sex.

The exact same thing happened with Langit Makin Mendung. Those who condemned this story refused to read and understand the whole work, focusing instead on some small parts.

While in the case of Langit Makin Mendung people were offended by the personification of Allah and Muhammad, in the latter case, the rector was only questioning the opening part of the story referring to rahim (womb), sperma (sperm) and the sentences saying that “no men will enter their thing into yours” and also, “I will not like men but will like women.”

By any means, these words and the sentences are there not to make readers aroused, but to build the fictional universe based on the writer’s imagination. If some readers get sexually aroused by this part of the story, as the rector told the students during a closed meeting, it is no fault of the writer. Thus, there is no reason for the rector to replace the editors and staff.

Instead the rector’s action counters the spirit of Law No. 12/2012 on higher education, which encourages creativity, tolerance and critical thinking.

Above all, fiction is fiction, written based on the writer’s imagination. No individual or institution, not even the court, can intervene into one’s imagination. A fiction writer deserves absolute freedom that can only be limited by her own reason and conscience.

I believe that the judges have gotten it terribly wrong. But the damage has been done, and the second cut could be much deeper.

Realizing the profound impact of the case, the verdict should be reviewed by a higher court. We may lose the battles, but hopefully, in the end, we can win the war.


Novelist and expert witness for students of North Sumatra University (USU) in a trial against the Suara USU student website, PhD candidate, former resident writer and visiting fellow at National University of Singapore.

Published in The Jakarta Post Trials of fiction: We lose the battle again


1965 A Teeuw AA Navis Academic Journal Aceh Achdiat Kartamihardja Agnez Mo Agus Yudhoyono Ahmadiyah Ahok Aktivisme Anarchism Angga Sasongko Apsanti Djokosujatno Arswendo Atmowiloto ASEAN Asrul Sani Atambua Australia Indonesia Azab Bahasa Melayu Bakhtin Bebalisme Belu Bencana Benedict Anderson Bertahan Bookfluencer Bound BRIN, Megawati Soekarnoputri, Ideologi Pancasila Burkini Capitalism Censorship Cerita Perjalanan Cerpen Children's Day Children's Literature Clifford Geertz Colonialism Coronavirus Corruption Crazy Rich Crazy Rich Asians Decolonising Knowledge Deleuze Democracy Detik Dhjksh Dinasti Disabilitas Dorce, Transgender Education Education Edward Said Egg Boy Emile Durkheim Engaged Literature Entrok Faisal Tehrani Fanon Feminism Feminism Film Film Foucault Freedom Freedom Of Expression Friedrich Engels Gapi Gayatri Spivak Gebunden Gempa Bumi Gender Equality Genealogi Gili Meno Gojek Griffith Review Gus Dur Habermas Hamka Hamzah Fansuri Hari Buruh Hari Ibu Hari Kartini Hijab Hikayat Kadiroen History Human Human Rights Humanity Humor HUTRI76 Identitas Imlek Indonesia Gender Research Islam Islam Istirahatlah Kata-Kata Jagal Jalaluddin Rakhmat Jawa Pos Joko Pinurbo Jose Ramos Horta Joshua Oppenheimer Jurnal Perempuan Kapitalisme Karl Mannheim Kartini Kebebasan Kebebasan Kebebasan Berekspresi Kekerasan Seksual Kekuasaan Kekuasaan Kelas Menulis Kelas Pemikiran Kelas Penulisan Kennedy Kerumunan Terakhir Khashoggi Kids Kipandjikusmin Kompas Korupsi KPK Leviathan Lewat Djam Malam LGBT Literature Literature Lombok Makar Malay Manifesto Mannheim Maryam Maryam Mata Mata Dan Nyala Api Purba Mata Dan Rahasia Pulau Gapi Mata Di Tanah Melus Max Havelaar May Day Media Research Media Sosial Mendikbud Menulis Opini Mobilitas Sosial Multatuli Mural Nadiem Makarim Natal Nawal El Saadawi New Naratif Nh Dini Nkcthi Novel Baswedan OM Institute OMG! My Story OMInstitutePrograms Omong-Omong Media Orientalism Ortega Gasset Padang Pariaman Pandemi Papua Pasung Jiwa Pelatihan Menulis Pembunuhan Sosial Perempuan Phuket Polisi Virtual Politics Politik Politik Bahasa, Pornography Law Pramoedya Privilege Psychoanalitical Puisi Puisi Pulau Buru Racism Raffi Ahmad Ramadan Ramon Grosfoguel Religion Religiusitas Resensi Revolusi Akhlak Revolusi Mental Riset Gender RKUHP Roland Barthes Sabir Laluhu Saras Dewi Sarjana Sartre Sastra Sastra Sastra Anak Sastra Perlawanan Science Of Fictions Sejarah Bahasa Selametan Semaoen Seni Menulis Opini Seni Menulis Skripsi Seri Mata Sexuality Silsilah Duka Singapore Social Dilemma Social Media Socrates Solo, Solitude Sosiologi Agama Soul Suara USU Subaltern Sumatra Sumpah Pemuda Syariah Law Syed Farid Alatas Syed Hussein Alatas Syed Naquib Alattas Syekh Siti Jenar Tahun Baru Teknologi Teror Thailand The Act Of Killing The Glass Castle The Jakarta Post The Last Crowd The Years Of The Voiceless Thomas Hobbes Timor Leste Tips Skripsi Tommy F Awuy Translation Travel Travel Writing Tsunami Tuhan Aku Lapar Usmar Ismail UU ITE Vaksin Covid19 Voice Wawasan Kebangsatan Wiji Thukul WijiThukul Women Of Letters Wonder Writing Workshop Xenophobia Yang Bertahan Dan Binasa Perlahan